Hook and Hartley Wintney GPs are 1,060 patients over capacity, the NHS says, and it wants £3.66m from Murrell Green. National Highways has extended its hold.

The two GP surgeries that would serve the 2,160 homes planned at Murrell Green are already 1,060 patients over capacity, the NHS has told Hart District Council.

NHS Hampshire and Isle of Wight Integrated Care Board (ICB) wants the developer to pay £3,656,340 towards a new surgery, or £2,240,052 to extend the existing ones. Without that money, it says, it would object.

The ICB’s letter of 10 November was added to Hart’s planning register on 11 November. A day later, National Highways asked Hart not to grant permission before 12 February 2027. It had already asked for a hold to 13 November.

The application, reference 26/01201/OUT, is from Lightwood Land Ltd. It seeks outline permission for up to 2,160 homes between Hook and Hartley Wintney, with schools, a local centre and green space.

What the NHS says about GP surgeries

The ICB names the two surgeries whose catchments cover the site. Both are run by Whitewater Health:

  • Hartley Wintney Surgery, 1 Chapter Terrace
  • Hook Surgery, Reading Road

Its calculation, set out in an appendix to the letter, runs like this:

Patients
What the two surgeries are built for 17,034
Patients registered now 18,094
New residents from Murrell Green (2,160 homes x 2.44 people) 5,270
List size if the scheme is built 23,364
Over capacity if the scheme is built 6,331

The ICB says the surgeries are now at 106% of capacity. It works out that the new residents would need 395.28 square metres of extra GP space.

Bar chart of the patient list at Whitewater Health's Hook and Hartley Wintney surgeries: built for 17,034 patients, 18,094 registered now, and 23,364 if the 2,160 Murrell Green homes are built, according to NHS Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB.
The NHS figures for the two surgeries. Chart by Fleet & Hook News
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

It priced that space two ways:

  • A new purpose-built surgery: £3,656,340, or £1,693 per home
  • An extension to one or both existing surgeries: £2,240,052, or £1,037 per home

The ICB says the choice has not been made yet. It will write again, before any decision date, to confirm which project it and Whitewater Health prefer.

It warns that without the money, “waiting times would increase and access to adequate health service would decline”. It also says people who cannot see a GP “may present themselves at the Emergency Department”.

Why National Highways has extended its hold

National Highways looks after the M3. The site sits just north of the motorway, east of Junction 5 at Hook.

Its formal recommendation of 12 November says permission should not be granted until 12 February 2027. That gives the applicant time to supply more information.

The main sticking point is traffic. National Highways says it “cannot accept” the developer’s claim that its travel plan would cut two-way car trips by a third. It also wants:

  • the method used to share out where trips go, so it can test the assumptions
  • evidence that the base traffic model has been properly calibrated
  • motorway growth rates used for growth on the M3
  • money for the travel plan’s measures ring-fenced, with more paid if targets are missed

The recommendation does not stop Hart refusing the application, or agreeing a longer extension, if it wishes.

Where the application stands

The scheme is still registered, with no committee date. Hart’s register showed 576 comments from the public on 14 November: 571 objections and one in support.

Hampshire County Council’s education team has objected unless school land and about £49.7 million are secured. Four parish councils want the scheme refused. Our October report has those objections in full.

What it means for you

  • Patients at Hook and Hartley Wintney surgeries: the NHS figures say the two practices already have more patients than their buildings are designed for. Any money from this scheme would only pay for extra space if permission is granted and the homes are built.
  • No decision before February. Hart cannot grant permission before 12 February 2027 unless it consults the Secretary of State for Transport.
  • You can still comment. Search 26/01201/OUT on Hart’s planning register. The NHS and National Highways letters are both on the documents tab.
  • The wider choice is in the Local Plan. Hart’s consultation on where homes should go runs until 7 December. Our report: Hart Local Plan consultation.